Exhume by Danielle Girard

Posted November 3, 2016 in Book Review / 0 Comments

Exhume by Danielle GirardExhume by Danielle Girard
Series: Dr. Schwartzman #1
Published by Thomas & Mercer on October 1st 2016
Genres: Mystery, Crime, Thriller, Suspense
Pages: 400
Format: eBook
Source: Amazon Kindle First
Buy on Amazon

This is an affiliate link you can use to purchase the book. If you buy the book using that link, I will receive a small commission from the sale.


Dr. Annabelle Schwartzman has finally found a place to belong. As the medical examiner for the San Francisco Police Department, working alongside homicide detective Hal Harris, she uncovers the tales the dead can’t tell about their final moments. It is a job that gives her purpose—and a safe haven from her former life at the hands of an abusive husband. Although it’s been seven years since she escaped that ordeal, she still checks over her shoulder to make sure no one is behind her.
Schwartzman’s latest case is deeply troubling: the victim bears an eerie resemblance to herself. What’s more, a shocking piece of evidence suggests that the killer’s business is far from over—and that Schwartzman may be in danger. In this pulse-pounding thriller from award-winning writer Danielle Girard, a woman must face her worst nightmare to catch a killer.

Main points


This is a long book so I decided to keep track of my thoughts as I went along because I knew I would forget stuff. It turned out to be a lot of thoughts, but it makes sense—long book = long review. Fasten your seatbelts, friends.

About 35%

This is going to be a long book.

Okay, looks like we’ve got two different storylines going on here—but as this isn’t an episode of CSI, they’ve got to converge at some point. I’ll wait.

Oooh, alternating POVs. If I really felt invested in Schwartzman as a character, I might mind. But I don’t.

Man, what is it with Schwartzman’s POV and only using last names? It must be annoying having to write “Schwartzman” so many times. I’m already tired of it. I dunno, it’s kind of weird. (Note: later I realize that actually only a couple of names in this POV are last-name-only, but Schwartzman continues to always be last-name in the narration. Other people call her various things.)

I forgot how much I liked crime novels. I love all these missing or disparate pieces that will eventually click. I also love the mystery surrounding Spencer and the fact that stalkers are not usually murderers. Two very separate things with undeniable connections/coincidences.

About 65%

Okay like Schwartzman is so weak. She’s doing everything wrong. This guy’s clearly a psychopath and she falls to pieces wherever he’s concerned. She’s just egging him on like that. Anyway, I wouldn’t leave her alone if I knew the threat was getting larger—she needs a bodyguard at this point UGH. Everyone’s an idiot.

Why in hell would she go back to SC? Like does she not even take herself seriously? She’s walking into a trap and she knows it and she’s not even taking the proper precautions. Does she want to f— her life over even more? And why is her mother such a b—? God, just forget about her, she’s not going to be of any use here…

Thank god at least Hal is being helpful to the SC investigation, since Schwartzman is being, like, a negative help. Anti-help. A hindrance. She’s keeping too much to herself. Like, she was keeping everything about Spencer to herself before, for obvious reasons, but once that cat was out of the bag she continued to clam up about stuff that would actually be super helpful for people to know. Like what, does she want them to nail this guy or what? Does she really want to keep living this life of silent fear and terror of Spencer just so she doesn’t have to talk about it and face her past and her present issues? Or does she want to finally face it and help them put him behind bars? Jesus, grow up, woman. It’s been too long for it to be that painful to think about. Hell, I might not know what I’m talking about, but I know what the rational decision would be, and she’s letting her emotions rule her. I agree with Harper, it’s funny how such a strong woman could be so easily under his thumb, even still. Did I say funny? I meant frustrating as hell.

But like, back to her being the pure opposite of helpful—she’s basically like View Spoiler » I’m probably being incredibly unfair because I do understand how a victim is manipulated by a psychopath but it continues to boggle my brain how it’s possible.


Have I ranted enough? Probably. Maybe not though. So let’s look at what happened…

Spoiler version: View Spoiler »

Hm, what can I say that will give you an adequate idea of what happened without spoiling…Well, I can say that I was unpleasantly surprised by what happened, and it wasn’t because the ending was obviously unhappy, but rather because the ending seemed too convenient and ridiculous. But hopefully it’s not as convenient as it appears to be because the series continues. That’s my hope.

(That wasn’t a rant, but the spoiler version definitely was.)

Overall, I did like the book. I loved the crime-mystery aspect of it. It was detailed and intriguing. Kept me on my toes. I’m all for that, really. I love CSI and such. The other characters were all right; even Spencer was realistic and appropriately hate-able and subtly terrifying. But Schwartzman…man, that woman frustrated me no end. Literally. Until the end (and I’m sure beyond), she did not improve even a fraction in my eyes. I liked it when she finally took control of her situation, until she used that control to make some really stupid decisions. Nothing in the book gave me the tools or the reasons to understand and possibly forgive her, and unfortunately, even my seemingly endless empathy has its limits.

 reaction upon finishing

all righty then. glad that worked out so well for her, now I can finally be rid of her

this book in one word


About Danielle Girard

Almost two decades ago, Danielle decided she wanted to try to write a book. She set out to write something sweet, maybe even romantic, but on page 5, someone got shot and it’s been that way ever since.

The Barry-award winning author lives with her husband, who is careful never to lurk in dark corners, and their two children. They split their time between San Francisco and the northern Rockies.

Overall: three-stars


Sign up here to receive ALL of Awesome Book Assessment's posts in your inbox!

Nose Graze - WordPress themes and plugins for the creative blogger

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Notify of